| Impact World Championship | Sami Callihan | 25 Oct 2019 to 11 Jan 2020 | 79 |
| AAW Heavyweight Championship | Sami Callihan | 29 Dec 2018 to 27 Sep 2019 | 273 |
| A1 Outer Limits Championship | Sami Callihan | 02 Dec 2018 to 02 Feb 2019 | 63 |
| KO-D Openweight Championship | Sami Callihan | 01 Aug 2018 to 07 Aug 2018 | 7 |
| HOG Crown Jewel Championship | Sami Callihan | 09 Jun 2018 to 14 Dec 2018 | 189 |
| Rockstar Pro Tag Team Championship | Clayton Jackson, Dave Crist and Sami Callihan | 02 Feb 2018 | 0 |
| Rockstar Pro Tag Team Championship | Clayton Jackson, Dave Crist and Sami Callihan | 02 Feb 2018 | 0 |
| Rockstar Pro Tag Team Championship | Dave Crist, Jessicka Havok and Sami Callihan | 05 Jan 2018 to 01 Feb 2018 | 28 |
| Rockstar Pro Tag Team Championship | Dave Crist, Jessicka Havok and Sami Callihan | 05 Jan 2018 to 01 Feb 2018 | 28 |
| WC Sideshow Championship | Sami Callihan | 02 Mar 2017 | 0 |
| Rockstar Pro Championship | Sami Callihan | 03 Feb 2017 to 02 Mar 2017 | 28 |
| AAW Heavyweight Championship | Sami Callihan | 08 Oct 2016 to 30 Aug 2017 | 327 |
| PW2.0 Heavyweight Championship | Sami Callihan | 02 Aug 2016 | 0 |
| FCP Championship | Sami Callihan | 08 Jul 2016 to 22 Sep 2016 | 77 |
| Rockstar Pro Championship | Sami Callihan | 01 Jun 2016 to 01 Sep 2016 | 93 |
| PWX Heavyweight Championship | Sami Callihan | 21 May 2016 to 17 Jun 2016 | 28 |
| AAW Heavyweight Championship | Sami Callihan | 19 Feb 2016 to 22 Jul 2016 | 155 |
| 2CW Heavyweight Championship | Sami Callihan | 29 Nov 2015 to 19 Dec 2015 | 21 |
| Honorary CZW Junior Heavyweight Championship | Sami Callihan | 14 Jul 2012 | 0 |
| IWC Super Indy Championship | Sami Callihan | 23 Jun 2012 to 19 Oct 2012 | 119 |
| Honorary CZW Junior Heavyweight Championship | Sami Callihan | 13 Nov 2011 to 04 May 2012 | 174 |
| IPW World Championship | Sami Callihan | 18 Jun 2011 to 04 Nov 2011 | 140 |
| IPW World Championship | Sami Callihan | 18 Jun 2011 to 04 Nov 2011 | 140 |
| PWS Heavyweight Championship | Sami Callihan | 27 May 2011 to 01 Jun 2012 | 372 |
| JAPW Tag Team Championship | Chris Dickinson and Sami Callihan | 23 Oct 2010 to 22 Jul 2011 | 273 |
| F1 Heavyweight Championship | Sami Callihan | 29 Jan 2010 to 19 Aug 2010 | 203 |
| Ultraviolent Underground Championship | Sami Callihan | 25 Oct 2009 | 0 |
| CZW New Horror Championship | Sami Callihan | 14 Feb 2009 to 12 Jun 2009 | 119 |
| ICW Midwest Championship | Sami Callihan | 05 Sep 2008 to 31 Oct 2008 | 57 |
| IPW Junior Heavyweight Championship | Sami Callihan | 02 Aug 2008 to 05 Sep 2008 | 35 |
