| FTPW Championship | Samuel Shaw | 23 Jun 2018 to 19 Oct 2018 | 119 |
| Tried-N-True Championship | Samuel Shaw | 18 Mar 2017 to 04 Jan 2019 | 658 |
| USWA Heavyweight Championship | Sam Shaw | 18 Oct 2014 to 08 May 2015 | 203 |
| OVW Southern Tag Team Championship | Alex Silva and Sam Shaw | 28 Feb 2013 to 04 Apr 2013 | 36 |
| OVW Southern Tag Team Championship | Alex Silva and Sam Shaw | 02 Dec 2012 to 16 Jan 2013 | 46 |
| USWA Heavyweight Championship | Sam Shaw | 24 Mar 2012 | 0 |
| Vintage Heavyweight Championship | Sam Shaw | 14 May 2011 to 08 Jun 2012 | 392 |
| Vintage Heavyweight Championship | Sam Shaw | 17 Apr 2010 to 10 Sep 2010 | 147 |
| Vintage Heavyweight Championship | Sam Shaw | 30 May 2009 to 19 Feb 2010 | 266 |
