| NEW Tag Team Championship | Brian Anthony and Matt Taven | 13 May 2023 to 08 Jun 2023 | 27 |
| NEW Heavyweight Championship | Matt Taven | 17 Dec 2022 to 11 May 2024 | 512 |
| ROH World Championship | Matt Taven | 06 Apr 2019 to 26 Sep 2019 | 174 |
| NWA World Historic Welterweight Championship | Matt Taven | 30 Mar 2018 to 02 Aug 2018 | 126 |
| NEW Heavyweight Championship | Matt Taven | 16 Aug 2014 to 09 Jan 2016 | 512 |
| CW Tag Team Championship | Matt Taven and Vinny Marseglia | 16 May 2014 to 26 Jun 2014 | 42 |
| ICW Tag Team Championship | Matt Taven and Rhett Titus | 18 Oct 2013 | 0 |
| ROH World Television Championship | Matt Taven | 02 Mar 2013 to 13 Dec 2013 | 287 |
| CW New England Championship | Matt Taven | 07 Sep 2012 to 28 Sep 2012 | 22 |
| TRP Heavyweight Championship | Matt Taven | 08 Jun 2012 to 13 Jul 2012 | 36 |
| CW New England Championship | Matt Taven | 16 Mar 2012 to 18 Aug 2012 | 156 |
| TRP Heavyweight Championship | Matt Taven | 05 Aug 2011 to 05 Apr 2012 | 245 |
| On Fire Tag Team Championship | Julian Starr and Matt Taven | 10 Aug 2010 | 0 |
| NEW Heavyweight Championship | Matt Taven | 20 Mar 2010 to 29 Sep 2011 | 559 |
