| DDT Iron Man Heavy Metal Championship | Chris Hero | 11 Aug 2016 | 0 |
| APW Worldwide Internet Championship | Chris Hero | 13 Jun 2014 to 05 Sep 2014 | 85 |
| EVOLVE Championship | Chris Hero | 23 Feb 2014 to 07 Aug 2014 | 166 |
| IWA East Coast Heavyweight Championship | Chris Hero | 12 May 2010 to 11 Jul 2011 | 426 |
| PWG World Championship | Chris Hero | 06 Jul 2008 to 03 Sep 2009 | 425 |
| wXw World Tag Team Championship | Chris Hero and Marc Roudin | 24 Nov 2007 to 21 Jun 2008 | 211 |
| CZW World Heavyweight Championship | Chris Hero | 13 May 2006 to 08 Sep 2006 | 119 |
| IWA East Coast Heavyweight Championship | Chris Hero | 06 Apr 2005 to 14 Nov 2006 | 588 |
| CZW New Horror Championship | Chris Hero | 01 May 2004 to 10 Dec 2004 | 224 |
| GPW Heavyweight Championship | Chris Hero | 06 Mar 2004 to 16 Oct 2004 | 225 |
| GPW Heavyweight Championship | Chris Hero | 06 Mar 2004 to 16 Oct 2004 | 225 |
| XICW Intense Championship | Chris Hero | 13 Jul 2003 to 13 Sep 2003 | 63 |
| IWA World Championship | Chris Hero | 12 Jul 2003 to 01 Aug 2003 | 21 |
| wXw World Heavyweight Championship | Chris Hero | 01 Mar 2003 to 07 Nov 2003 | 252 |
| IWA World Championship | Chris Hero | 07 Feb 2003 to 06 Jun 2003 | 120 |
| IWA World Championship | Chris Hero | 12 Jul 2002 to 04 Oct 2002 | 85 |
| IWA World Championship | Chris Hero | 20 Oct 2001 to 04 Dec 2001 | 46 |
| VCW Tag Team Championship | Porno The Clown and Wife Beater | 27 Jan 2001 | 0 |
| ACW Championship | Chris Hero | 17 Nov 2000 | 0 |
| VCW Triple Threat Championship | Wife Beater | 01 Jan 1999 | 0 |
