| Unsanctioned Pro Hardcore Championship | John Wayne Murdoch | 23 Feb 2024 to 10 May 2024 | 78 |
| Horror Slam Heavyweight Championship | John Wayne Murdoch | 19 May 2023 to 10 Aug 2023 | 84 |
| GCW Ultraviolent Championship | John Wayne Murdoch | 31 Mar 2022 to 04 Jun 2022 | 66 |
| Horror Slam Deathmatch Championship | John Wayne Murdoch | 01 Sep 2021 to 12 Jan 2023 | 499 |
| IWA Tag Team Championship | Jake Crist and John Wayne Murdoch | 15 Apr 2021 to 02 Jun 2021 | 49 |
| ICW American Deathmatch World Championship | John Wayne Murdoch | 10 Apr 2021 to 21 Jan 2022 | 287 |
| IWA World Championship | John Wayne Murdoch | 08 Apr 2021 to 14 Apr 2021 | 7 |
| VOW Anarchy Championship | John Wayne Murdoch | 01 Sep 2018 | 0 |
| IWA World Championship | John Wayne Murdoch | 03 May 2018 to 18 May 2018 | 16 |
| IWA World Championship | John Wayne Murdoch | 05 Jan 2017 to 24 Feb 2017 | 51 |
| IWA World Championship | John Wayne Murdoch | 07 Jul 2016 | 0 |
| IWA World Championship | John Wayne Murdoch | 27 Nov 2015 to 03 Dec 2015 | 7 |
| IWA World Championship | John Wayne Murdoch | 09 Oct 2015 | 0 |
| EPW Openweight Championship | John Wayne Murdoch | 11 Oct 2014 | 0 |
| USWO Heavyweight Championship | Damien Payne | 07 Dec 2012 to 13 Dec 2012 | 7 |
| USWO Heavyweight Championship | Damien Payne | 28 Sep 2012 to 29 Nov 2012 | 63 |
| USWO Music City Championship | Damien Payne | 07 Jul 2012 to 02 Aug 2012 | 27 |
| USWO Music City Championship | Damien Payne | 07 Jul 2012 to 02 Aug 2012 | 27 |
| USWO Music City Championship | Damien | 30 Apr 2010 to 26 Aug 2010 | 119 |
| USWO Music City Championship | Damien | 30 Apr 2010 to 26 Aug 2010 | 119 |
| USWO Tag Team Championship | Damien Payne and Josh Crow | 23 Oct 2009 to 18 Feb 2010 | 119 |
| USWO Tag Team Championship | Damien Payne and Josh Crow | 21 Aug 2009 to 10 Sep 2009 | 21 |
| USWO Tag Team Championship | Damien Payne and Josh Crow | 10 Apr 2009 to 23 Jul 2009 | 105 |
| USWO Tag Team Championship | Damien Payne and Josh Crow | 13 Feb 2009 | 0 |
| USWO Tag Team Championship | Damien Payne and The New York Gangster | 22 Aug 2008 to 25 Dec 2008 | 126 |
| USWO Tag Team Championship | Damien Payne and LT Falk | 30 May 2008 to 12 Jun 2008 | 14 |
| USWO Music City Championship | Damien Payne | 04 Apr 2008 to 19 Jun 2008 | 77 |
| USWO Music City Championship | Damien Payne | 04 Apr 2008 to 19 Jun 2008 | 77 |
