| BTW Heavyweight Championship | RJ Brewer | 21 Mar 2014 to 21 Mar 2014 | 1 |
| LLUSA Heavyweight Championship | RJ Brewer | 20 Oct 2013 to 20 Oct 2013 | 1 |
| LLUSA Heavyweight Championship | RJ Brewer | 18 Jun 2011 to 19 Oct 2013 | 855 |
| BTW Heavyweight Championship | John Walters | 28 Jun 2008 to 28 Mar 2009 | 274 |
| 2CW Heavyweight Championship | John Walters | 11 Apr 2008 to 11 Apr 2008 | 1 |
| BTW Heavyweight Championship | John Walters | 12 May 2007 to 28 Mar 2008 | 322 |
| NECW Heavyweight Championship | John Walters | 18 Mar 2006 to 09 Jun 2006 | 84 |
| ROH Pure Championship | John Walters | 28 Aug 2004 to 04 Mar 2005 | 189 |
| ECWA Unified Heavyweight Championship | John Walters | 01 May 2004 to 18 Feb 2005 | 294 |
| CW Heavyweight Championship | John Walters | 16 Jan 2004 to 11 Mar 2004 | 56 |
| EWA Heavyweight Championship | John Walters | 31 Jan 2003 to 21 Mar 2003 | 50 |
| EWA New England Championship | John Walters | 20 Dec 2002 to 21 Feb 2003 | 64 |
| CW Heavyweight Championship | John Walters | 16 Aug 2002 to 04 Apr 2003 | 232 |
| CW New England Championship | John Walters | 07 Sep 2001 to 15 Feb 2002 | 162 |
