| NGW Eastern States Championship | Caleb Konley | 08 Jul 2023 to 11 May 2024 | 309 |
| RWA World Heavyweight Championship | Caleb Konley | 18 Mar 2023 to 08 Dec 2023 | 266 |
| PWR Scramble Championship | Caleb Konley | 20 Oct 2018 to 09 May 2019 | 202 |
| AML Championship | Caleb Konley | 25 May 2018 to 26 Nov 2018 | 186 |
| WCWC Pacific Northwest Championship | Caleb Konley | 06 May 2018 to 07 Jul 2018 | 63 |
| AML Prestige Championship | Caleb Konley | 25 Feb 2018 to 28 Apr 2018 | 63 |
| WCWC Pacific Northwest Championship | Caleb Konley | 06 Feb 2016 to 04 Mar 2016 | 28 |
| PPW Tag Team Championship | Caleb Konley and Drew Donovan | 01 Jan 2016 | 0 |
| FIP World Heavyweight Championship | Caleb Konley | 03 Jul 2015 to 26 May 2016 | 329 |
| WCWC Legacy Championship | Caleb Konley | 28 Feb 2015 to 03 Jul 2015 | 126 |
| PPW Heavyweight Championship | Caleb Konley | 09 Dec 2014 to 08 Apr 2015 | 121 |
| WCWC Tag Team Championship | Caleb Konley and Mikey O'Shea | 05 Jul 2014 | 0 |
| WrestleForce Championship | Caleb Konley | 09 Feb 2014 to 29 Mar 2014 | 49 |
| PWX Heavyweight Championship | Caleb Konley | 23 Feb 2013 to 24 May 2014 | 456 |
| PWX Heavyweight Championship | Caleb Konley | 06 Jul 2012 to 29 Nov 2012 | 147 |
| EWA Junior Heavyweight Championship | Caleb Konley | 28 May 2011 to 25 May 2012 | 364 |
| PWI Ultra J Championship | Caleb Konley | 07 May 2011 to 08 Jun 2012 | 399 |
| PWI Ultra J Championship | Caleb Konley | 14 Dec 2007 to 16 May 2008 | 155 |
| DSW Tag Team Championship | Caleb Konley and Sal Rinauro | 26 Jul 2007 to 01 Aug 2007 | 7 |
| DSW Tag Team Championship | Caleb Konley and Sal Rinauro | 26 Jul 2007 to 10 Oct 2007 | 77 |
| ACW Super H Title | Suicide | | 0 |
