| FTW World Heavyweight Championship | Balls Mahoney | 23 Jul 2011 to 09 Sep 2011 | 49 |
| USA Pro Heavyweight Championship | Balls Mahoney | 01 Jan 2011 | 0 |
| FTW World Heavyweight Championship | Balls Mahoney | 18 Jul 2009 to 20 Nov 2009 | 126 |
| IWA Puerto Rico Hardcore Championship | Balls Mahoney | 01 Apr 2006 to 14 Apr 2006 | 14 |
| MAW Heavyweight Championship | Balls Mahoney | 06 Jan 2006 to 06 Apr 2006 | 91 |
| USA Pro Heavyweight Championship | Balls Mahoney | 15 Apr 2005 to 23 Sep 2005 | 162 |
| USA Pro Heavyweight Championship | Balls Mahoney | 19 Nov 2004 to 14 Apr 2005 | 147 |
| IWC World Heavyweight Championship | Balls Mahoney | 13 Nov 2004 to 10 Dec 2004 | 28 |
| USA Pro Heavyweight Championship | Balls Mahoney | 17 Jan 2003 to 30 May 2003 | 134 |
| USA Pro Heavyweight Championship | Balls Mahoney | 30 Aug 2002 to 18 Oct 2002 | 50 |
| ACW Heavyweight Championship | Balls Mahoney | 08 Jun 2002 to 22 Aug 2002 | 76 |
| USA Pro Heavyweight Championship | Balls Mahoney | 11 Jan 2002 to 16 Aug 2002 | 218 |
| ACW Hardcore Championship | Balls Mahoney | 23 Aug 2001 to 13 Sep 2001 | 22 |
| USA Pro Heavyweight Championship | Balls Mahoney | 03 Jun 2001 to 25 Aug 2001 | 84 |
| XICW Heavyweight Championship | Balls Mahoney | 08 Apr 2001 to 02 Jun 2001 | 56 |
| USA Pro Heavyweight Championship | Balls Mahoney | 18 Feb 2001 to 17 Mar 2001 | 28 |
| ECW World Tag Team Championship | Balls Mahoney and Spike Dudley | 14 Aug 1999 to 25 Aug 1999 | 12 |
| ECW World Tag Team Championship | Balls Mahoney and Spike Dudley | 18 Jul 1999 to 12 Aug 1999 | 26 |
| ECW World Tag Team Championship | Balls Mahoney and Masato Tanaka | 01 Nov 1998 to 05 Nov 1998 | 5 |
| MEWF Mid-Atlantic Championship | Boo Bradley | 13 Oct 1996 to 30 Nov 1996 | 49 |
| SMW Beat The Champ Television Championship | Boo Bradley | 06 Feb 1995 | 0 |
| SMW Beat The Champ Television Championship | Boo Bradley | 05 Sep 1994 to 02 Oct 1994 | 28 |
