| CWE Canadian Unified Junior Heavyweight Championship | Austin Aries | 17 Feb 2023 to 17 Feb 2023 | 1 |
| X-LAW Heavyweight Championship | Austin Aries | 19 Mar 2022 to 11 May 2024 | 785 |
| PPW Heavyweight Championship | Austin Aries | 21 Sep 2019 to 18 Oct 2019 | 28 |
| WSW Heavyweight Championship | Austin Aries | 24 Jun 2018 to 25 Nov 2018 | 155 |
| Impact World Championship | Austin Aries | 24 Apr 2018 to 13 Oct 2018 | 173 |
| DEFY World Championship | Austin Aries | 13 Apr 2018 to 19 Jul 2018 | 98 |
| Impact Grand Championship | Austin Aries | 14 Jan 2018 to 03 Jun 2018 | 141 |
| Impact World Championship | Austin Aries | 10 Jan 2018 to 21 Apr 2018 | 102 |
| IPW World Championship | Austin Aries | 17 Dec 2017 to 28 Apr 2018 | 133 |
| Defiant World Championship | Austin Aries | 05 Dec 2017 to 27 Apr 2018 | 144 |
| WSW Heavyweight Championship | Austin Aries | 27 Nov 2017 to 21 Jun 2018 | 207 |
| EPW Heavyweight Championship | Austin Aries | 17 Oct 2015 to 07 Oct 2016 | 357 |
| Impact X-Division Championship | Austin Aries | 07 Jan 2015 to 07 Jan 2015 | 1 |
| Impact X-Division Championship | Austin Aries | 20 Jun 2014 to 24 Jun 2014 | 5 |
| Impact X-Division Championship | Austin Aries | 16 Jan 2014 to 01 Mar 2014 | 45 |
| Impact X-Division Championship | Austin Aries | 23 Nov 2013 to 04 Dec 2013 | 12 |
| Impact X-Division Championship | Austin Aries | 20 Jun 2013 to 28 Jun 2013 | 9 |
| Impact World Tag Team Championship | Austin Aries and Bobby Roode | 25 Jan 2013 to 10 Apr 2013 | 76 |
| Impact World Championship | Austin Aries | 08 Jul 2012 to 13 Oct 2012 | 98 |
| Impact X-Division Championship | Austin Aries | 11 Sep 2011 to 04 Jul 2012 | 298 |
| ROH World Championship | Austin Aries | 13 Jun 2009 to 12 Feb 2010 | 245 |
| ROH World Championship | Austin Aries | 26 Dec 2004 to 17 Jun 2005 | 174 |
| PWW Heavyweight Championship | Austin Aries | 12 Dec 2004 to 17 Dec 2005 | 371 |
| NWA Midwest X-Division Championship | Austin Aries | 06 Sep 2003 to 08 Apr 2004 | 216 |
| SDW Tag Team Championship | Dan Sexon and Ted Dixon | 18 Jul 2003 | 0 |
| SDW Tag Team Championship | Dan Sexon and Ted Dixon | 18 Jul 2003 | 0 |
| MAW Junior Heavyweight Championship | Austin Aries | 22 Mar 2003 | 0 |
| Neo Pro Cruiserweight Championship | Austin Aries | 17 Aug 2002 to 11 Oct 2002 | 56 |
| MIW Cruiserweight Championship | Austin Aries | 09 Feb 2002 to 13 Dec 2002 | 308 |
