| REVOLVER Championship | Alex Shelley | 24 Jan 2024 to 10 May 2024 | 108 |
| SFC Thrash Zone Title | Alex Shelley | 01 Oct 2023 to 11 May 2024 | 224 |
| Combat 1 Crash Title | Alex Shelley | 18 Aug 2023 to 11 May 2024 | 268 |
| Impact World Championship | Alex Shelley | 09 Jun 2023 to 12 Jan 2024 | 218 |
| PWR Remix Championship | Alex Shelley | 12 Nov 2022 to 15 Mar 2024 | 490 |
| Prestige Championship | Alex Shelley | 12 Mar 2022 to 23 Mar 2024 | 743 |
| Prestige Championship | Alex Shelley | 20 Feb 2022 to 10 Mar 2022 | 19 |
| IWTV Independent Wrestling World Championship | Alex Shelley | 08 Oct 2021 to 20 Jan 2022 | 105 |
| BLP Midwest Championship | Alex Shelley | 03 Oct 2020 to 02 Sep 2021 | 335 |
| XICW Midwest Heavyweight Championship | Alex Shelley | 17 Apr 2016 to 04 Jun 2016 | 49 |
| Smash Wrestling Championship | Alex Shelley | 23 Nov 2014 to 14 Mar 2015 | 112 |
| Impact X-Division Championship | Alex Shelley | 11 Jan 2009 to 14 Mar 2009 | 63 |
| IWGP Junior Heavyweight Tag Team Championship | Alex Shelley and Chris Sabin | 04 Jan 2009 to 04 Jul 2009 | 182 |
| MCW Cruiserweight Championship | Alex Shelley | 11 Nov 2006 to 24 Mar 2007 | 134 |
| NWA International Lightweight Tag Team Championship | Alex Shelley and Chris Sabin | 25 Aug 2006 to 05 Apr 2008 | 590 |
| UWA Light Heavyweight Championship | Alex Shelley | 28 Jul 2006 to 22 Mar 2007 | 238 |
| NWA Midwest X-Division Championship | Alex Shelley | 06 May 2006 to 04 Jan 2007 | 244 |
| UWA Light Heavyweight Championship | Alex Shelley | 13 Jan 2006 to 25 May 2006 | 133 |
| ZERO-ONE United States Heavyweight Championship | Alex Shelley | 13 Sep 2005 to 22 Nov 2005 | 71 |
| ZERO-ONE United States Heavyweight Championship | Alex Shelley | 13 Sep 2005 to 22 Nov 2005 | 71 |
| ZERO-ONE United States Heavyweight Championship | Alex Shelley | 13 Sep 2005 to 22 Nov 2005 | 71 |
| ZERO-ONE United States Heavyweight Championship | Alex Shelley | 13 Sep 2005 to 22 Nov 2005 | 71 |
| Honorary CZW Junior Heavyweight Championship | Alex Shelley | 08 Jan 2005 to 04 Feb 2005 | 28 |
| BCW Can-Am Television Championship | Alex Shelley | 19 Sep 2004 to 16 Apr 2005 | 210 |
| BCW Can-Am Television Championship | Alex Shelley | 19 Sep 2004 to 16 Apr 2005 | 210 |
| BCW Can-Am Television Championship | Alex Shelley | 19 Sep 2004 to 16 Apr 2005 | 210 |
| XICW Light Heavyweight Championship | Alex Shelley | 16 May 2004 | 0 |
| wXw World Heavyweight Championship | Alex Shelley | 19 Dec 2003 | 0 |
| wXw World Heavyweight Championship | Alex Shelley | 08 Nov 2003 to 18 Dec 2003 | 41 |
| GLW Cruiserweight Championship | Alex Shelley | 28 Sep 2002 to 24 Jun 2004 | 636 |
| GLW Cruiserweight Championship | Alex Shelley | 28 Sep 2002 to 24 Jun 2004 | 636 |
